In Les Riceys, two wines born of the same gesture tell of two landscapes

by PASCAL IAKOVOU
0 comments

Same grape variety, same vintage, same ageing, same dosage: on paper, Les Vignes Blanches 2020 and Hardy 2020 should resemble each other like twins. Nothing of the sort. In Les Riceys, Domaine Alexandre Bonnet proves, through these two cuvées, that a few hundred metres are enough to radically change the face of a Pinot Noir.

The exercise is an almost scientific demonstration, rare in the world of Champagne, where blends most often seek to smooth out differences rather than expose them. By varying only one parameter, the plot, while keeping the grape variety, the 2020 vintage, the ageing and the dosage identical, Domaine Alexandre Bonnet offers anyone who wishes a comparative tasting lesson directly legible in the glass, without needing to know the theory beforehand. This stance presupposes particular confidence in the raw material: presenting two deliberately different wines, rather than seeking the harmony of a single blend, means accepting to let the terroir express itself unfiltered, even when it produces two results that might seem to compete on the shelves.

To the east of the village, Les Vignes Blanches delivers a wine of flesh, carried by energy and notes of yellow fruit that reflect generous exposure to the sun. To the north, on the Hardy plot, the same Pinot Noir changes register and takes shape in tension, freshness and a verticality that winegrowers generally associate with cooler terroirs, less directly exposed. This opposition between flesh and tension, between solar energy and mineral rectitude, is less a hierarchy than an invitation to understand what exposure, altitude and the nature of the soils concretely imprint on a single grape variety. The choice of the names themselves, Les Vignes Blanches and Hardy, refers directly to the lieu-dit from which each cuvée comes, anchoring the tasting from the outset in a precise geography rather than in a fanciful name disconnected from the ground.

This approach is part of a broader movement in contemporary Champagne, where a growing number of houses choose to tell the story of their terroirs through the plot rather than through the brand signature alone, even at the cost of complicating their commercial offer in order to gain geological legibility. Benjamin Courant, the estate’s vineyard manager, embodies this meticulous plot-by-plot approach, which requires an intimate knowledge of each parcel in Les Riceys in order to draw from it, year after year, readings as precise as those offered by this 2020 diptych. In Les Riceys, this work takes on particular relief: the diversity of exposures and soils in the village allows a variety of readings that the comparison between Les Vignes Blanches and Hardy brings out with rare clarity.

Presenting side by side two wines so close in their making and so different in their expression amounts, ultimately, to asking a simple question that is rarely put so directly: what remains of the winegrower’s gesture once the terroir has had the last word? Domaine Alexandre Bonnet seems to have chosen to answer it not in theory, but by letting two bottles side by side settle the debate themselves. The estate also remains available to organise an exchange with Benjamin Courant around this reading of terroirs, a sign that the approach is meant to be as educational as it is commercial.

Also on Luxsure: Alexandre Bonnet, the Coteaux Champenois, or Champagne without effervescence · Domaine Alexandre Bonnet’s Coteaux Champenois 2022, a quiet reading of Pinot… · Boizel Rosé Absolu: the balance of the Champagne meridians · Lanson Le Rosé Création: anatomy of a Champagne blend

Cette publication est également disponible en : Français (French) Deutsch (German) Italiano (Italian) Español (Spanish) العربية (Arabic) 简体中文 (Chinese (Simplified)) 日本語 (Japanese) Русский (Russian) Ελληνικά (Greek)

LUXSURE LETTER

Le luxe, sélectionné plutôt que subi.

Recevez notre sélection éditoriale consacrée aux Maisons, aux idées et aux mutations qui façonnent le luxe contemporain.

RECEVOIR LUXSURE LETTER → DÉCOUVRIR LE MAGAZINE →

Related Articles